XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute

Discus and support XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute in XBoX on Consoles to solve the problem; I'm copying the post that DavidIQ wrote about this issue since it was "locked" without any kind of resolution. I want to keep this topic going in case... Discussion in 'XBoX on Consoles' started by BondxGirl, Jun 12, 2019.

  1. BondxGirl
    BondxGirl Guest

    XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute


    I'm copying the post that DavidIQ wrote about this issue since it was "locked" without any kind of resolution. I want to keep this topic going in case someone comes up with a solution or finds something out.

    _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    I'm having the same exact issue that this person posted in this
    thread that was started a month ago
    that was for some reason considered "old" and then locked with no resolution:

    The external HDD (Seagate STDT3000300 BACKUP PLUS Desktop 3TB, USB3.0, 3.5 inch external drive, powered by external power) of my Xbox One keeps spinning up for a few seconds then spinning down again a few seconds later and this cycle repeats every
    60 seconds exactly. So every minute the HDD has to spin up and then back down again.


    My settings are that the XBOX is in instant on mode, with auto update of the console as well as games and apps enabled.

    It has been suggested in other threads that this behaviour is a result of auto updating of apps and games, but even when all auto-updates are turned off this behaviour continues, so changing this setting makes no difference.

    The Xbox shouldn't need to keep spinning up an external HDD every minute. It should be able to know what version of what updates are installed for each game on each HDD without having to interrogate the HDD every 60 seconds. It can cache it surely?
    Constantly spinning up and down HDD's is terrible for the lifespan of the HDD, and is annoying if the HDD is a little noisy, is unnecessary. Please implement a mechanism that doesn't require cycling the HDD power every 60 seconds.


    Aside from the external drive being a different brand (mine is a WD) this is the exact issue I'm experiencing and have also had the settings the same as them. As I had said over in that thread I've been having this issue since I've had the external drive.
    The hard drive works fine when plugged into a computer only spinning when actually accessed. This tells me that the Xbox is doing something in the drive, but what exactly if all settings are set in a way that this shouldn't happen. I think we can safely throw
    out the window any assumption that there's something wrong with anyone's external hard drive. It's also clear that resetting the console is not and should not be the solution for the many users that have been having this exact problem.

    I had read elsewhere that the constant spinning was due to one of the installed games having a pending message and that once the person found which game it was they cleared the message and the constant re-spinning stopped. But finding that game in 200+ installed
    games would be next to impossible. This just needs the proper attention from Microsoft. For now I have the external hard drive plugged into the front of the console and just unplug it whenever I'm not using the console.

    Since I'm posting this as a question: Is this being addressed? Having to unplug my external drive when not in use so that its lifespan is not cut short by this issue seems a little excessive and tiresome.

    :)
     
    BondxGirl, Jun 12, 2019
    #1
  2. zzIRISMAXIMUSzz Win User

    XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute

    It might be worth looking into a USB port splitter. I use Sabrent 4-Port USB 3.0 Hub with Individual Power Switches. It allows you to shut off and turn on whatever you have plugged in. I use two external
    hard drives with this.
  3. RAXXIC Win User

    XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute

    Hi Andy5416,

    It seems like you have a strange one there.

    I have had a similar problem with my old Seagate HDD to which I had found out that it was due to a faulty USB head. I understand you have already tried another HDD but may I ask did you change the cables for testing?

    Regards

    Rax
  4. Andy5416 Win User

    XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute

    Attempted to turn off the option to power down drive so that it would be always on, but even then it spins down and up again every minute. So it seems no matter what setting it's on, it will not

    1. keep drive powered on when in standby

    or

    2. keep drive powered off when in standby

    So if it's doing a status check every 60 seconds, is it the drive that is spinning up on its own, or is it the XBOX OS that is spinning it up I wonder?

    I have another drive which I have plugged in and tried this on, it is a Hitachi Touro 1tb (usb powered hdd) and it also spins up every 60 seconds. I plugged the hitachi into another XBOX one S and noticed it exhibited the identical behaviour... Spinning
    up and down every 60 seconds.

    So that's two drives on two Xbox One's. I'm very puzzled. Thoughts?
  5. Alucario Ultra Win User

    XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute

    Try to hard reset the console, one never knows.
  6. EXES5 Win User

    XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute

    Its just keepin it alive and not alowing it to sleep.if it goes to sleep whatever needs access to your external just stutters til the hard is back on or even freezes.
Thema:

XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute

Loading...
  1. XBOX One external hard drive keeps spinning up and down every minute - Similar Threads - external hard drive

  2. External Hard Drive

    in XBoX on Consoles
    External Hard Drive: External 2Tb Seagate My Xbox One required an update this morning when i turned it on and after updating my external drive turned off and wont come back on. The drive is only a month or two old...
  3. External Hard Drive lag issues

    in XBoX on Consoles
    External Hard Drive lag issues: So my external hard drive has been working fine up until recently. When a game starts a cut scene, it will lag(the scene stops and starts over and over) and when the scene ends, the game play...
  4. External hard drive

    in XBoX on Consoles
    External hard drive: I have a one s with an external hard drive that works perfectly fine. I got a new one x and tried to use the external hard drive but it will not recognize it. Does anyone know what the problem is?...
  5. External hard drive.

    in XBoX Accessibility
    External hard drive.: my external hard drive was working perfectly on my new xbox one s and all of a sudden the xbox just could not detect the drive anymore, ive both factory reset and hard reset the console, i plugged...
  6. How to eject an external hard drive in xbox?

    in XBoX on Consoles
    How to eject an external hard drive in xbox?: How can I properly eject an external hard drive on Xbox One? ec4c9099-e29e-4e9f-bb50-6eb892451c0c
  7. Using an external hard drive with an xbox one S

    in XBoX on Consoles
    Using an external hard drive with an xbox one S: I've used up almost all of my 1 TB capacity on my xbox one s, so I was thinking of getting an external hard drive. I've never used one before, so I have a few questions. First, should I...
  8. External hard drive will not load games

    in XBoX on Consoles
    External hard drive will not load games: Okay so I have been having this issue for a while and I finally figured out that my external hard drive is the problem. I have a WD passport 2TB and it's only about 10 months old. Not all but most...
  9. External hard drive not registering

    in XBoX on Consoles
    External hard drive not registering: Frustrated this is our second external hard drive that the XBox isn't showing in the storage area? I am at my breaking point to throw the system out my door. We have the X Box S the white system...
  10. External Hard Drive not staying connected to Xbox One

    in XBoX on Consoles
    External Hard Drive not staying connected to Xbox One: Lately I have been having trouble with my external hard drive not staying connected or not connecting at all. A week or so ago I had to reset my Xbox and that went smoothly but just a few days ago...